The Australian government’s eSafety Commissioner found itself in a powerless predicament as it attempted to police online content.
Chris Elston, known online as ‘Billboard Chris,’ refused to comply with demands to delete an ‘offensive’ post about a UN trans expert, despite the threat of a hefty fine.
Even after Elon Musk’s X platform geo-blocked the post in Australia, Elston defiantly reposted it, triggering a massive viewership as others joined in making the post go viral.
Does Australia’s eSafety Commissioner, Julie Inman Grant, have a personal vendetta against @elonmusk?
She is a former Twitter employee who has accused Musk of allowing “sewer rats” back onto the platform.https://t.co/lPqUSfnQAE
— Billboard Chris 🇨🇦🇺🇸 (@BillboardChris) March 27, 2024
The eSafety Commissioner, promoted as a ‘world’s first’ in online safety regulation, revealed its powerlessness, admitting it can only act upon new complaints from offended parties to remove subsequent posts.
This revelation led to criticism from political figures, with David Limbrick MP condemning it as a waste of taxpayer money, and Moira Deeming likening it to Orwell’s ‘Ministry of Truth’.
The eSafety Commissioner has brought our nation into disrepute. I want to feel proud to be Australian. I want Australia to be a beacon of freedom in the world. Instead, the world laughs at our stupidity. We need to shift towards the defence of freedom.
— David Limbrick MP 🌸 (@_davidlimbrick) March 26, 2024
Australia, look at this e-commissioner & her “Ministry of Truth”.
We reject your Orwellian dystopia. https://t.co/wla3y7rs5A— Moira Deeming MP (@MoiraDeemingMP) March 26, 2024
The commissioner, led by disgruntled former Twitter employee Julie Inman-Grant, faces scrutiny over its hefty budget and its handling of cases involving overseas individuals.
I’m working on an appeal of the Australian eSafety Commissioner’s ruling. @elonmusk and @X are not the only ones who can legally appeal this. I can too.
Speech tyranny must be fought. https://t.co/LMUTD4h1I0
— Billboard Chris 🇨🇦🇺🇸 (@BillboardChris) March 27, 2024
Elston’s original post shared a news story about a contentious WHO trans activist, Teddy Cook, leading to a demand for removal by the eSafety Commissioner.
The incident has sparked debates around government throttling of freedom of speech and the role of online regulators in a global context.
