THE UK Bar Council has publicly come out after the Russel Brand rape trial saying “defendants have a right to have evidence tested in court” as the country’s legal establishment defend their ideologically tainted system.
Brand’s defence barrister Ian Winter KC, has been indirectly accused by the UK Justice Secretary Alex Norris of employing “rape myths” after the barrister questioned why accusers had not resisted, screamed, or tried to leave during the alleged rapes, which Brand has repeatedly denied.
The new Labour Prime Minister Andy Burnham, appointed Norris, an MP, as Secretary of State for Justice and Lord Chancellor in July this year.
The six complainants have their identity fully protected while courtroom reporting on these cases is highly restrictive. Kelly said that would protect any complainant who was a serial fabulist. “The whole system is stacked against the defendant,” she said.
Mr Winter also questioned why the complainants didn’t come out during the Me Too movement and why one complainant “didn’t just roll over and kick out”. He also suggested Brand could not have raped “just three” of the “many, many women” he had slept with.
The alleged offences took place between 20 and 30 years ago when Brand was rising to fame as a left-wing TV media star and led a highly promiscuous lifestyle that made some rock stars look tame.
He is now reformed as a professing Christian and has shifted from left wing politics to a strongly anti-left, anti-globalist position.
Brand was never accused of rate until UK media companies dredged up a list of “sexual abuse victims” from Brand’s past promiscuous lifestyle that he admitted to in his own autobiography.
The comments by Brand’s lawyer sparked counter allegations from the leftist camp claiming Winter was engaging in “victim blaming”. Mr Winter disputed how his remarks were reported.
But a Bar Council spokesman had to remind The Times of “justice 101” – that a defendant denying a rape offence has a “right to have evidence tested in court and for the prosecution to prove it to the criminal standard of being sure or beyond reasonable doubt”.
The trial resulted in Brand being sentenced on November 5th to 10-and-a-half years in prison for one count of rape and three counts of sexual assault.
In his letter to the BSB Mr Norris said the board “must send a strong signal to the profession on the harm arising from rape myths, and that the perpetuation of such myths within a court room is unacceptable, just as they are unacceptable in our society at large.”
Norris was basically spouting feminist “Me Too” propaganda, which has attacked the legal system as part of “the patriarchy” and being inherently biased against female victims. The comments strongly suggest Brand’s trial may well have been corrupted by this attack on legal standards.
As highlighted by Adelaide law professor Dr Joanna Howe, the Me Too movement’s demands are currently being inserted into Australian law through various pieces of legislation making criticism of “women and gender equality” an offence.
The Metropolitan Police, who have gained notoriety for politically-tainted policing, jumped into the debate, with the Commissioner Sir Mark Rowley also claiming reported courtroom arguments bordered on “victim blaming,” and that trauma causes many people to “freeze” rather than fight (even after 20-30 years?)
The new Justice Secretary, apparently trying to score points for his Labour Party, doubled down on his rape myths argument, and in his letter to the Bar Standards Board he called for strict new rules and potential disciplinary sanctions to stop barristers from “relying on misconceptions about how victims behave”.
However the Bar Council and Criminal Bar Association argued that defendants have a fundamental right to have evidence rigorously tested in court, and warned that extra restrictions or compulsory rules based on the “rape mythology” could drive more specialists away from an already depleted pool of sexual-offence defence barristers.
The UK Labor government is, of course, all for the Me Too movement and the “rape mythology” arguments with so-called mandatory jury directions versus judicial independence.
A proposed amendment to the Courts and Tribunals Bill is backed by Victims’ Commissioner Claire Waxman, Sir Mark Rowley, and has been tabled in the House of Lords by Baroness Alison Levitt KC. It would legally require judges to direct juries on “rape myths” in every sexual offence trial.
The fact that the UK has a Victims Commissioner speaks to the inroads made by the Me To movement and other feminist organisations.
Commenting on the case, Canadian lawyer Viva Frei, said the UK was no longer the place of western values where you could expect a fair judicial hearing. “It’s a country as far as I’m concerned that you should avoid visiting and if you can avoid living in it as well,” he said.
“This entire process – unfair is an understatement when you’re facing anonymous victims, there’s no statute of limitations on some of these charges, so you’re dealing with things that are 25, 30 years old and I say this you know, whether they are legitimate or not, at some point of time a sufficient passage in time has occurred that justice for the victim or the accused is impossible.
“